In the past, Anabelle had lost her shoe to a monster but he graciously returned it to her without letting her know that the shoe is possessed by his spirit. While casually sitting, she notices that her pump chafes against her foot, as if there is a rock in it. Slipping it off, she leaves it on the ground and crosses her leg while flexing and wiggling her toes.
Everything feels better for a bit, until she feels a strange force field emanating from her empty shoe. It is as if it wants to communicate with her and she stands up while rubbing her shoeless foot up and down her calf. The force field pulls her back to the couch and she realizes that the shoe monster has control of her shoe and the only way to get it back is to follow its instructions.
Hesitantly she goes along and follows his commands of using the heel to tear a hole in the foot of her nylons. Her cute toes and bare sole are exposed and she is surprised when he asks for a special foot job using her big toe and 2nd toe on the high heel. It dawns on Anabelle that the shoe monster, while devious, does not want to hurt her and just wants to enjoy her sexy feet.